listen here

Or you can mail donations to Henry Shivley at P.O. Box 964, Chiloquin, OR 97624

Arizona Man Winds Up Jailed, Unemployed and Homeless After Photographing Courthouse

Raymond MichaelPhotography is not a Crime – by Carlos Miller

Raymond Michael Rodden was bored this week, so he drove to downtown Phoenix and began walking around, snapping photos of the federal courthouse and the state capitol with his iPhone.

The 33-year-old man ended up jailed, unemployed and homeless; his iPhone, iPad and Macintosh laptop confiscated as “evidence.”  

All because they found it odd he was taking photos at 3 a.m.

“They told me they’re going to keep my computer because they want to see my search history,” he said Saturday evening in a telephone interview with Photography is Not a Crime.

“They wanted to know if I belonged to any extremist groups like the national socialist movement or sovereign citizens. They wanted to know what kind of books I checked out of the library.”

However, the only charges pending against him, if you even want to call them charges, are citations that he walked into an alley – a bogus charge that applies only to motorized vehicles –  and that he neglected to change the address on his driver license after moving to Phoenix from Tucson last August.

They couldn’t even keep him jailed on the initial charge of an outdated warrant out of California because the San Obispo County Sheriff’s Office did not want to bother extraditing him from Phoenix.

“The warrant was not even valid in Arizona,” adding that it was over a probation violation for unlawful use of a vehicle, stemming from a 2001 incident in which he took his roommate’s car without permission after a heated argument.

That old roommate is still one of his best friends, allowing him to stay in his Tucson home after he was kicked out of the Phoenix home that was part of his employment.

“I was living in my boss’s house taking care of his son,” he said. “Now he thinks I’m some crazy person.”

The fact that the Phoenix police bomb squad tore his boss’s car apart searching for explosives before impounding it most likely convinced him that Rodden was not the most suitable person to care for his six-year-old son as he worked as a long-distance truck driver.

“The most radical thing I do is read Photography is Not a Crime and Cop Block,” he said.

So like most people who read those sites, he knows his rights when it comes to dealing with police.

And that is exactly why he is going through this ordeal.

It started Thursday at 3 a.m. when he was sitting at home, unable to sleep. He decided to drive to downtown in his boss’s car, which he had permission to do.

He parked the car in front of the Phoenix Police Department and began walking around downtown, which is a ghost town at that time.

Sandra Day O'Connor United States Courthouse

He snapped photos of the Arizona State Capitol and the Sandra Day O’Connor United States Courthouse, two of the city’s most picturesque buildings.

He exchanged pleasantries with Federal Protective Service officers guarding the courthouse, who are probably the ones who called police on him.

He continued walking when he noticed he was being followed by a Phoenix police patrol car. Before he knew it, he was being followed by an additional two marked cars as well as an unmarked car, not to mention a cop on foot.

“I kept walking around because I knew if I got into my car, they would pull me over,” he said.

They kept trying to talk to him but he kept asking if he was being detained and they said no, so he kept walking and they kept following, He walked around for more than an hour as the cops kept following, waiting for him to slip up.

That was when he walked into an alleyway, thinking he was not breaking any law.

Little did he know that Phoenix Municipal Code 36-61 states that “no person shall use an alley within the city as a thoroughfare except authorized emergency vehicles.”

“As soon as I walked into the alley, they descended upon me,” he said.

As one PINAC reader pointed out in the comments section, this code applies to vehicles, not pedestrians.

But before he knew it, he was handcuffed and sitting in an interrogation room at the Phoenix Police Department, fielding questions from an FBI agent and a police detective named Darren Emfinger from the Joint Terrorism Task Force as to what organizations he belonged to and what types of books he reads.

“I told them I was not doing anything illegal by taking photos and they kept saying, ‘we’re not disputing that it’s illegal, we just find it odd,’” he said.

Meanwhile, they discovered that a key in his backpack fit a Toyota Tundra that was sitting in front of their building, so they called the bomb squad to dismantle it in the hopes they would find something illegal.

“It was a complete overreaction,” he said.

When they couldn’t connect him to any terrorist activity, they jailed him on the outdated warrant, where he remained until 2 p.m. after they realized they had no legal grounds to hold him.

Once he left jail, he walked back to the police department to retrieve his backpack, which contained his laptop, iPhone, iPad and an external hard drive, but was told that it was being kept as “evidence.”

When he got back home, his boss told him to pack his bags.

“I tried to explain what had happened but they had already talked to him,” he said.

So he headed down to Tucson where he is staying with a friend.

“I’m afraid they are going to keep digging and digging until they find something to nail me with,” he said. “That is why I got out of Phoenix.”

Darren Emfinger, the Phoenix police detective and joint task force member who has been featured in the The First 48 television show and who is refusing to return his items, can be reached at  (623) 466-1398 or on his cell phone, (602) 377-9108.

The Arizona ACLU, whom he hopes will help him in this case, can be reached at or 602.650.1854.

Phoenix Mayor Greg Stanton can be reached at or 602-262-7111.

This entry was posted in News. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Arizona Man Winds Up Jailed, Unemployed and Homeless After Photographing Courthouse

  1. NC says:

    Hey, maybe if someone was videotaping the whole incident and then handing over the footage to those same police officers or their chief, then this guy would still have his job, the cops wouldn’t have done anything to him and he could still be living at the place he was staying in.

    Let’s all think about that for a moment.


  2. NC says:

    I guess we all need government permission to take a picture of a government building nowadays. So sad.

    Who cares if it was a 3am. As a photographer, maybe he was doing a presentation or piece on government buildings at night or maybe he just found it interesting to be able to take a picture of the damn building when there weren’t a ton of people in his way or in his view. Terrorism? Oh puhlease! But what do you expect from Police State America.

  3. anonymous says:

    “Real” photographers do NOT, I repeat, do NOT seek confrontation
    with “Am I being detained?”.

    “Real” photographers step up to the plate.
    Hello Sir. I am xxxx. Here is my ID, (show picture id).
    I am here because xxxxxx.

    You want a photograph, you will get it.
    You want to create an incident, you can get that as well.

    Arresting him is their JOB. His behavior was more than “odd”.
    No patience from me. I’ve been in this circumstance.
    I got my shot. Not jail.

    • NC says:

      Your name says it all.

    • justsayin says:

      Yes we have to show picture ID BECAUSE? Remember the government building belongs to we the people not the government. We still have some freedoms from tyranny, Don’t you agree? Photography is still legal. Do you want to show your ID for all legal purposes? F@#$ them for requiring it. This is all just a devide and conquer routine repeated in history many times over so everyone reports everyone else to the Gov. Forget the Bible, forget the “love thy neighbor”, report everything to the tyrannical scumbags. Is that really the life you want? Devoid of love ruled by fear? always on the defense?

    • Millard says:

      “Your papers please”,

    • # 1 NWO Hatr says:

      Apparently you don’t mind kissing a little ass.

      Obviously why you wish to remain anonymous.

  4. justsayin says:

    Is it their job to arrest and question you for doing legal things you shill? We now have to beg and justify legal things? It is OK to be detained asked for papers please, as in Nazi Germany? Yes lets put the police in the bathrooms too. Papers please just why are you using this particular bathroom, in this place. Is your business #1 or #2? –What was the last time you did #2 in this bathroom? That is suspicious. Do you own a pressure cooker? Were you ever taking pictures at the World Trade Center? Did you ever use the bathroom there? People grow a set of Balls.

    • Henry Shivley says:

      So, justsayin, where’d you get them rose colored glasses? No, please tell us what you really think. And by the way, I concur. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *