Monsanto’s SmartStax maize ‘to be approved for growth in October’ in EU

AFP Photo / Johannes EiseleRT News

A controversial, genetically modified super-maize from Monsanto is set to be approved for cultivation across the European Union by late October despite safety concerns, German media reports.

Despite EU regulators last month thwarting the expansion of the world’s largest seed corporation, it appears Germany won’t escape new GMO crops.   

“The decision rests with the European Commission, which will agree with the import in September or October,” a spokesperson for the EU Consumer Protection Commissioner, Tonio Borg, told Germany’s Zeit Online. The spokesperson said the decision would come after a “rigorous, scientific evaluation process.”

SmartStax GM maize was developed in the US by Monsanto and Dow AgroSciences. It combines the genes of two already genetically modified maize varieties. SmartStax is resistant to two types of herbicides and poisons against six different species of insects, such as the European corn borer. The seed includes eight artificially added genes – previously, the biggest number of such genes added to a single plant was three.

Monsanto and Dow AgroSciences have been lobbying for SmartStax in Europe for the last five years, having first applied for EU marketing approval in 2008.

In 2010, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) concluded that SmartStax was “as safe as conventionally bred maize and commercial versions in regard [to the] potential impact on the health of humans, animals and on the environment.”

A study completed the next year also came to the same conclusion – that SmartStax was safe.


AFP Photo / Volker HartmannAFP Photo / Volker Hartmann


But GM-critical German consulting company Testbiotech has repeatedly criticized EFSA for serious gaps in its safety assessment of SmartStax maize. The original GM varieties of maize that SmartStax was engineered from were tested in a 90-day trial of GM plants being fed to humans. Reportedly, SmartStax has never been scientifically tested on animals in Europe and therefore “the risk assessment performed by the EFSA is actually not adequate to sufficiently exclude adverse effects on humans, animals and the environment,” Testbiotech says on its website.

Independent European experts say that the cultivation of SmartStax is extremely controversial, because long-term tests of the new maize have not been conducted.

“This case shows that decisions made by the Commission on permitting genetically engineered plants in food and feed are not sufficiently based on science but on economic pressure. Just because US companies want unrestricted import of these types of maize into Europe, the EU Commission is continuing the authorization process and refusing to acknowledge the actual risks,” said Christoph Then, a representative of Testbiotech.

“This is a serious threat to consumers and the protection of health and the environment,” said Then, who also is Greenpeace Germany’s expert on agriculture genetic engineering. “No other already approved plant contains so many genetically modified ingredients. It is completely unclear how they interact and what consequences this has long-term.”

In June, Testbiotech wrote to the European Commission, about for their risk assessment of SmartStax maize.

In the commission’s reply, officials insisted that SmartStax maize had been thoroughly tested and had received a “favorable opinion” from the EFSA as safe to be sold on the European market.

Testbiotech blasted the EU Commissioner’s reply as “misleading,” and voiced concerns that the risk assessment of SmartStax showed that there was “no thorough examination in this case” as the EFSA did not initiate an independent study for the market authorization of the corn.

Monsanto refused to comment on the upcoming authorization to Zeit Online, but stated that its products had been “assessed by various international authorities as safe” and the safety of Monsanto’s products would be “occupied by a huge amount of data and a variety of studies.”

The biotech giant said that the European approval of its seeds would be “in the interests of general world trade, and also for imports into the EU.”

While Monsanto look likely to win this round, the corporation has dropped its bid to get more genetically modified crops onto the European market, due to “widespread popular opposition.”

If the SmartStax gets the green light, it will be in line with France’s decision to re-open the door to Monsanto products. In early August, one of the country’s top administrative courts reversed a ban on genetically modified MON810 corn, which had been in place since March 2012. The court explained that the EU moratorium on the GMO corn lacked a legal basis.

One thought on “Monsanto’s SmartStax maize ‘to be approved for growth in October’ in EU

  1. Ladies and Gentlemen,

    We send you this mail to highlight an important global petition.
    A petition titled “Monsanto go home” was recently established by the European (against) Lobbyists Union (EULU).
    The petition can be found at:

    Monsanto takes on the world’s food resources and relies wholly on 100% genetic engineering in the fields of the world. Monsanto will meet EU groups to obtain approval for import inot the EU of “SmartStax” corn. Smartstax is a genetically modified (GM) corn that has eight GM traits as well as a tolerance to two herbicides (glyphosate and glufosinate).
    Monsanto has to be stopped.
    Do we want this in Europe and around the world?
    Please sign this petition as well as the citizens’ initiative. You can also help you by spreading them bring throughout Europe and to all parts of the world. You can add it your website, mail it to your friends, relatives and work colleagues.

    For a future without genetic engineering and without Monsanto, we need to act now!
    For more information about Monsanto
    Thank you very much for your attention

    With friendly greetings
    Werner Nosko
    Vienna, Austria
    EUropean Lobbyists Union

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published.