Nun Calls for Universities to Propagandize for Gun Control

Franciscan Sister Margaret CarneyAmmoLand – by Dean Weingarten

Arizona – -( The President of a private Catholic university was interviewed by The Catholic News Service, which is *not* a part of the Catholic Church.

It was published in  The Pilot, a paper that claims the title of “America’s Oldest Catholic Newspaper“.   The paper is owned by the Archdiocese of Boston.  

On June 1, it published an interview with Sister Carney, who has been the President of Bonaventure University, a private school in Allegany, New York, for the last ten years.

Here she speaks of the emotional plea for more government restrictions on the private ownership of firearms after the killing of six people in Santa Barbara, California, three with a knife, three shot to death:

Sister Carney said if she had heard this heartfelt plea three years ago, she would have been convinced something would change.

But that was before the school shooting two years ago at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut, where a 20-year-old gunman killed 20 students and six educators before killing himself.

“If Sandy Hook wasn’t enough for people to march to their senators and say, ‘We need a new (gun control) law tomorrow,’” she said she doesn’t know what will make the difference.

It does not appear the Sister Carney is completely uninformed about the Second Amendment and the public debate about the efficacy of more gun control.  She says:

“Of course college presidents are against gun violence; no one is in favor of that. But where do you stand on Second Amendment rights? That’s where conversation starts to fall apart,” she said.

She also noted that college presidents all have boards of trustees that are as “divided as the nation on the best approach” to gun control, which is why she thinks the best way forward is to commit to changing attitudes through education.

It becomes clear what she thinks the answer is: More propaganda aimed at changing public views, because, obviously, she believes the public views are wrong:

She also knows such a process will take years to make an impact, so it needs to be something college leaders are committed to for the long haul. But she believes it can happen, just as public views on cigarette smoking have changed over time.

As she put it: “Legal action will fail” without public support.

The interviewer assumes that more government restrictions are what Sister Carney is talking about;  they make the following statement:

 Currently, public support of gun restrictions is not strong. According to Pew Research Center studies, Americans briefly showed support for gun restrictions after the Sandy Hook shooting but then soon returned to stronger support for gun rights, particularly after a background check gun bill failed in the Senate.

Government restrictions of guns has not worked to prevent mass murders and is unlikely to work.  Every restriction pushed after Sandy Hook was already in place in California when the knife, gun, and car attack occurred in Santa Barbara,  so pushing propaganda to change public opinion about more government restrictions of guns is not the answer.  This appears to be a standard, run of the mill secular “progressive” answer: the solution is always more government restrictions.

What shocked me is that there is not one word in the article calling for a resurgence of faith.   Not one word talking about the power of redemption and Christian morality.   Not one word considering the power of prayer.    This is a Catholic nun in charge of a Catholic university, speaking in what purports to be the Catholic News Service, published in a Catholic paper, but the interview is completely secular, political, partisan, and cynical.

There is no consideration that “gun control” might be a failed idea, or that the more that people learn about “gun control”, the more that people oppose it.  There is no call for the civilizing influence of Christian belief.   To my knowledge, none of the recent mass shooters have been Christians, which says something in a predominantly Christian nation.

Sister Carney could have been interchanged with any other “Progressive” operative.   Other than the word “Sister” in front of her name, there is no indication that the Christian faith has anything to do with her opinions, actions, or prescriptions.

I have to wonder if she considers murder to be a moral choice, or simply a result of bad circumstances?

Digging a little deeper into the Catholic News Service, I find that it is owned by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.   It appears to be the equivalent of the AP: a reliably progressive news organ.   On another forum, many informed me that it is *not* a reliable source for Catholic Church doctrine.

c2014 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice is included. Link to Gun Watch

About Dean Weingarten;

Dean Weingarten has been a peace officer, a military officer, was on the University of Wisconsin Pistol Team for four years, and was first certified to teach firearms safety in 1973. He taught the Arizona concealed carry course for fifteen years until the goal of constitutional carry was attained. He has degrees in meteorology and mining engineering, and recently retired from the Department of Defense after a 30 year career in Army Research, Development, Testing, and Evaluation.

Read more:
Under Creative Commons License: Attribution
Follow us: @Ammoland on Twitter | Ammoland on Facebook

3 thoughts on “Nun Calls for Universities to Propagandize for Gun Control

  1. After a quick review of the history of the Catholic Church’s guidance to people and countries over the past centuries, I question the value of any of its recommendations now, especially if I do not agree with them.

  2. Good article, Mr. Weingarten.

    Some habit, sister. You are more proud of those worldly trappings than the traditional humble garb of a true Catholic sister who took the vows of poverty, chastity and obedience. (Do they even exist anymore?)

    Since Vatican II there is nothing Catholic about what is currently called the Catholic Church. It is in apostasy.

    Not even Christ himself would agree with “Sister” Carney and her Marxist poppycock. There is nothing moral about preventing people from protecting themselves. In fact, it is extremely immoral and violates the doctrine of the 5th Commandment: Thou shalt not murder. According to St. Alphonsus Liguori, the 5th Commandment is not violated if one must kill in self defense, to protect another’s life, to protect one’s property (but not a trifling value) or to protect one’s virtue.

    That Mother and Baby home in Tuam must have been run by the possessed, so wicked were they to do what they did. Pray for the innocent victims of these horrific crimes. No one has ever prayed for them before. They were not given a proper burial. What a disgrace and “Sister” Carney can’t see her hypocrisy in talking about gun control.

    Evil exists in people’s hearts.

    The purported Church leaders know little and nothing of its doctrine or dogmas of 2,000 years to say nothing of what is necessary for salvation. It’s no wonder God has turned its back on them and is allowing the Church to disintegrate.

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *