listen here

Or you can mail donations to Henry Shivley at P.O. Box 964, Chiloquin, OR 97624

NY Senate Passes Bill That Would Add Cops And Firemen To List Of Protected Classes Under State’s Hate Crime Law

Tech Dirt – by Tim Cushing

Because good ideas are rare but bad ideas eternal, the New York State Senate has just given its blessing to a stupid bill aimed at protecting people armed with guns, power, the weight of the law, and numerous immunity options. The “justification” for New York’s addition of cops and first responders to the state’s hate crime law is this:  

There has been an increase in mortality rates of law enforcement officers, firefighters, corrections officers and emergency medical services personnel, within the past decade. In a report by the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund in 2014, statistics showed that approximately “126 federal, state, local, tribal and territorial officers died in the line of duty” which exhibited an increase in comparison to 2012 and 2013. The increase in the death toll has been in part, due to offenses intentionally aimed to harm first responders.

This is followed by a bunch of anecdotes about officers and first responders being on the receiving end of supposedly “targeted” violence. It adds nothing to the “justification” but a few presentation-worthy stories to sway emotions of fellow legislators. It doesn’t make the preceding statement any more correct. It’s actually misleading and wrong in equal parts.

First off, an increase in “mortality rates” is not the same thing as an increase in violence directed at law enforcement officers. The stats legislators are attempting to point to include all deaths in the line of duty, whether they were at the hands of civilians or not. So, this stat is already sort of misleading, albeit only because of the way this bill’s sponsors have phrased it.

Second, the stats the justification quotes are wrong. There were 136 deaths in 2014, according to the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund. That’s more than what’s stated here. Worrying? Not even close. It’s 20 more than 2013, but one less than 2012’s total. In other words, the stats show no sort of increase that might justify giving police officers more protection. If these legislators weren’t trying to cherry pick, they might have included 2011’s total of 178, which is fifty more deaths than the supposedly-shocking number quoted in the bill’s justification.

Just so everyone’s aware who’s pushing to make an abusable law even more easily-abused, here’s the bipartisan group of sponsors.

Fred Akshar [R] – Longtime law enforcement officer, having served as undersheriff for Broome County before turning to politics.

Patrick M. Gallivan [R] – former Erie County Sheriff (1998-2005), preceded by 15 years with the New York State Police, and followed by a stint on the state parole board. One of several state legislators found to have faked leadership positions in the Senate to get a little unearned extra pay added onto their paychecks.

Tony Avella [D] – Last seen at Techdirt killing off his horrendous “Right to Be Forgotten” bill… but not in an honorable way. Rather than remove it from consideration, he simply revoked his sponsorship, leaving the orphaned bill to wander the Senate halls unattended.

Martin J. Golden [R] – A retired NYPD officer who has been instrumental in adding even more New Yorkers to the state’s sex offender registry, as well as expanding the state’s DNA databank to include people convicted of nothing more than a misdemeanor.

John J. Bonacic [R] – Former assistant district attorney and one of those guys who thinks something must be done about “anti-law enforcement rhetoric.” Apparently, this bill is part of the solution — a bill that could conceivably be twisted to turn “resisting arrest” into a felony-level hate crime. (Because what is “resisting arrest” if not “targeting” of law enforcement for abuse/violence/etc.?)

Here’s the pertinent wording of the bill, which adds cops, firefighters, and EMTs to a long list of groups who have historically been victims of discrimination.

section 1, states that a person has committed a hate crime, when he or she commits a specified offense and either intentionally selects the person against whom the offense is committed or intended to be committed to, or in part because of a belief or perception regarding race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, religion, religious practice, age, disability, sexual orientation of a person, or because of actual or perceived employment as a law enforcement officer, firefighter, or emergency medical services personnel.

Guess who doesn’t fit into that list: the shorter list of occupations that have long been revered, respected, and given considerable amount of leeway to perform their duties. Unlike those who have been singled out for abuse because of their age, disability, ancestry, race, color, national origin, or sexual orientation, the new protected class is entirely composed of voluntary “traits.”

Adding to the ridiculousness is the bill’s name — a self-righteous, heart-tugging melange of authority-worshipping words: Community Heroes Protection Act.

Very few bills of this sort have become law. Many have attempted to give more protection to well-protected powerful classes, but very few have garnered enough support to make it past the introduction stage. This one has moved forward, which is a problem because bills like this that have passed have immediately been abused by law enforcement.

https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170514/17013737366/ny-senate-passes-bill-that-would-add-cops-firemen-to-list-protected-classes-under-states-hate-crime-law.shtml

This entry was posted in News. Bookmark the permalink.
1273

3 Responses to NY Senate Passes Bill That Would Add Cops And Firemen To List Of Protected Classes Under State’s Hate Crime Law

  1. # 1 NWO Hatr says:

    “The increase in the death toll has been in part, due to offenses intentionally aimed to harm first responders.”

    WAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH! Cry us a river, b#tch!

    Couldn’t be directly correlated to the fact that in that same period, the pigs INTENTIONALLY MURDERED FAR MORE AMERICANS (mostly UNARMED ones) than ever before, could it?

    Just wait till the majority of the stupid sheeple wake up to that simple fact… you ain’t got the numbers, sh#t-fer-brains!

  2. NC says:

    “section 1, states that a person has committed a hate crime, when he or she commits a specified offense and either intentionally selects the person against whom the offense is committed or intended to be committed to, or in part because of a belief or perception regarding race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, religion, religious practice, age, disability, sexual orientation of a person, or because of actual or perceived employment as a law enforcement officer, firefighter, or emergency medical services personnel.”

    It amazes me how weak our police, fire department and EMS people have become. I’ve never heard of so many emergency personnel who claim to be so tough, yet they get easily offended by words and are constantly “in fear for their lives”.

    I guess they were never taught the old saying, “Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me”.

    Of course this whole bill is treasonous and also violates the 1st Article on a massive scale, but we all know that.

  3. GrinNBarrett says:

    Has anyone considered how they got this way. Here at home we were talking about it and came to the conclusion that the Nanny State and the adoptive process of rewarding trophies to everyone participating, Making sure everyone feel special and no one ever fails. The nanny state taking away games and equipment that might injure and you wonder why they are like this. They are created.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *