US will never apologize for Hiroshima, Nagasaki – President Truman’s grandson


The grandson of the man who ordered the nuclear bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki 70 years ago, recalled how he gradually became an advocate of nuclear-free world.

Clifton Truman Daniel is the son of President Harry Truman’s only child – fiction writer Mary Margaret, and Clifton Daniel, who worked as managing director for the New York Times. Clifton did not find out that his grandfather, who visited Daniel’s family on regular basis, had been the president of US until going to school, he told RT’s documentary channel RTD.  

Daniel learned that the US dropped nuclear bombs on Japan during wartime from history books and for many years felt no personal connection to the pivotal events of the 20th century.

“The bombs were a great thing. They ended the war. They saved hundreds o thousands of lives on both sides and that’s what my grandfather said was his reason for the decision. To shorten the war and save American lives that would likely be lost in an invasion of the main islands. I went from thinking about it in that way to not thinking about it, as I say, it was history,” he recalled.

The attitude changed one day as his son brought from school a book telling the story of Sadako Sasaki, who survived the bombing of Hiroshima at the age of two, only to fall to radiation-induced leukemia nine years later.

This general view of the city of Hiroshima showing damage wrought by the atomic bomb was taken March 1946 © STR

A Japanese legend promises that a wish would be granted to anyone who folds a thousand origami cranes. As Sasaki was battling the decease, she was making paper cranes in the hope of getting better. She died in 1955, her wish never granted.

As I said earlier my text book had numbers and reasons and planes and megatons. There wasn’t anything that happened to little girls,” Daniel said. “I went from not giving it much thought at all to being confronted one day with the reality that people lost their lives and in horrible ways and that has sort of brought me to the middle.”

Daniel became the first member of Truman family to visit Japan, when he took part in the commemoration of the victims of the bombings in 2012. He had been invited by Sadako’s older brother, Masahiro Sasaki.

The visit had its tough moments, Daniel recalled, for instance when he was interviewed by a Japanese journalist, who repeatedly asked him whether he would apologize for his grandfather’s decision, which he didn’t.

Clifton Truman Daniel © RTD

“I don’t know that there’ll ever be an apology. Maybe the two countries can find language that brings them together to say ‘you know we acknowledge that serious hurt was done on both sides and we own that and going forward we pledge not to do something like that’ but it doesn’t feel at this point that there will ever be a flat out apology from the US to Japan or the other way around,” he explained.

Harry Truman acted in good faith and believed he was saving many Americans’ lives, Daniel said. This was the prime consideration for the president, who had first-hand experience of battlefield during World War I and valued soldiers’ lives, he explained.

He admitted that controversy over Truman’s decision remains, as some people believe that the use of nuclear weapons was not necessary.

“The real question which we keep trying to answer but we can’t is did it in fact stop the war. Some people say no, Japan would have surrendered anyway; other people say they were not giving up, it stopped them cold,” Daniel said. “But we can’t know that because we did it and the war ended, so we don’t know how it would have gone.”

I think that Americans can still look at the decision and they can still say it was done for the right reasons,” he added. “They can also say look what it cost. They can have empathy. It doesn’t take anything away.”

People pray after releasing paper lanterns on a river facing the gutted Atomic Bomb Dome in remembrance of atomic bomb victims on the 66th anniversary of the bombing in Hiroshima August 6, 2011 © Kim Kyung-Hoon

7 thoughts on “US will never apologize for Hiroshima, Nagasaki – President Truman’s grandson

  1. Why should the US apologize to any thing. Other countries do not apologize for total destruction of populations.

  2. The nuking of both cities was and is still a very good thing. No matter if you believe it ended the war faster on better terms or if you believe it was an act of murder it remains a good thing. The destruction of both cities took the science behind a nuke and made it a reality for the average person, suddenly EVERYONE could see what just two mini-nukes by today’s standard could do. A precedent was set in all minds as to just what a nuclear war would look like not just in destruction of buildings; but also the pictures of people burned to ash, vaporized and others still living with chunks of burned flesh hanging off their bodies or eyes burned out.

    It removed deniability and innocence.

  3. “Harry Truman acted in good faith and believed he was saving many Americans’ lives, Daniel said. This was the prime consideration for the president, who had first-hand experience of battlefield during World War I and valued soldiers’ lives, he explained.”

    BULLSHIT! Truman knew what he was doing. He was doing the bidding of the Military Industrial Complex which was to test fire the new bomb weapon on Japan even AFTER Emperor Hirohito stated he was preparing to surrender. He didn’t help shorten the war. He helped murder thousands of lives for the elite. There’s no honor in that.

  4. I can’t believe in todays world anyone thinks nuclear weapons are a good thing. The only one who wins in the use of these weapons is the Grim Reaper as his indifference to how death is achieved matters not, only the amount of death.

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *