Couple Fined $10,000 After Refusing to Host Same-Sex Marriage on their Farm

Opposing Views – by Lina Batarags

The owners of a farm in upstate New York were fined $10,000 plus $3,000 in damages after they declined to host a same-sex wedding ceremony on their property. Now they’re fighting back.

Cynthia and Robert Gifford open up their farm property every autumn and host fall festivities to supplement their income. The Giffords live in a barn they built on the farm; occasionally, they also allow the bottom portion of their barn and the backyard area to be used for weddings.  

ADF reports that in September 2012, Cynthia Gifford received a call from Melisa McCarthy, who was inquiring about the use of the farm for her upcoming same-sex wedding.

Gifford told McCarthy that, because of her Christian faith, she and her husband do not host same-sex wedding ceremonies; however, she left the invitation open to consider the farm as a potential reception site.

McCarthy and her partner had, unbeknownst to Gifford, secretly recorded the conversation. McCarthy and her partner then went on to file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights that proved to be successful.

The New York State Division of Human Rights ruled that Cynthia and Robert Gifford were guilty of “sexual orientation discrimination” in refusing to host the wedding. In addition to their fines, the commissioner ordered the Giffords to implement staff re-education training classes that teach the state’s viewpoint on marriage.

On Thursday, an attorney filed a petition in New York state court that asked for a review of the New York State Division of Human Rights’ decision.

The appeal filed in Gifford v. New York State Division of Human Rights argues that the commissioner did not consider the Giffords’ constitutional freedoms and religious beliefs.

“All Americans should be free to live and work according to their beliefs,” said James Trainor, a private attorney allied with the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF). “Entering the marketplace doesn’t mean the government can force a person to surrender their First Amendment freedoms or face punishment.”

Trainor alleged that the commission demonstrated “stunning disregard for the Giffords’ First Amendment rights, which were never considered at a hearing.”

“The commissioner’s order in essence gives an ultimatum: host same-sex marriage ceremonies or none at all,” Trainor continued.

As reported by Life Site News, the Giffords have opened their property up to a lesbian couple hosting a birthday party for their child.

Trainor went on to say that government “should not force anyone to choose between their faith and their livelihood, but that’s exactly what has happened here.”

“The Constitution prohibits the state from forcing people to promote a message that violates their religious beliefs and conscience. Particularly disturbing is that, in this instance, it’s happening in someone’s own home,” said Trainor.

Sources: Alliance Defending Freedom, Life Site News

Photo Sources: Alliance Defending Freedom, Life Site News

– See more at:

4 thoughts on “Couple Fined $10,000 After Refusing to Host Same-Sex Marriage on their Farm

  1. My Fellow Americans:

    This is a perfect example of the how these pyscho-pathic, mentally deranged commies try to force their perversions onto to everyone in their zeal to destroy the moral foundations this country was built on!

    Kudos to the Robert and Cynthia Gifford for holding their ground!!!

    I can only hope they, the Giffords, understand this Criminal Cartel ensconced in Washington DC, will not tolerate martyrs to the Republic or to our God given, Hard-fought-for, Unalienable, Inalienable Birth Rights,…. to NOT have to peddle the sicko, homo/lesbian, nation destroying dogma of a bunch of perverted loons who masquarade as a gov’t body!!!

    JD – US Marines – The Criminal Cartel masqurading as the US Fed Gov’t are nothing more than a collection of complete sicko’s, perverts. loons and criminals,.. there is only one way they will ever allow the restoration of the Republic,.. they must be forcibly removed,.. before they exterminate us.


  2. A person secretly recorded the phone call, that is against the law, so the case is moot But the government will ignore that because this is a homosexual issue and the government shills are kissing the dykes ass..

    I need a new calculator.

  3. New York is a one party state. Only one party has to know they are being recorded, thus the lesbian recording it would be the one party.

  4. What ever happen to freedom of religion? It only applies to all others than Cristians? If only they were muslims…THAT would surely be different.

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published.