French schools are set to replace the words ‘mother’ and ‘father’ with ‘Parent 1’ and ‘Parent 2’ following an amendment to a law which passed through French Parliament this week.
The new naming convention is ostensibly aimed at ending discrimination against same sex parents but critics argue that it “dehumanises” parenthood and may lead to rows over who gets classified as ‘Parent 1.’
The amendment, passed Tuesday as part of a wider plan to build a so-called “school of trust,” will also enforce mandatory school attendance for all three-year-olds.
“This amendment aims to root in law children’s family diversity in administrative forms submitted in school,” said Valérie Petit, MP for the majority REM party of President Emmanuel Macron.
“We have families who find themselves faced with tick boxes stuck in rather old-fashioned social and family models. For us, this article is a measurement of social equality.”
“I have already written that I’m particularly shocked and surprised at the ‘controversy’ around the parent/mother/Father forms,” Israeli-French former journalist Julien Bahloul, himself a same-sex parent, tweeted. “The mother and father are parents, nothing insulting to that. In #TelAviv the forms were changed a long time ago without any worries.”
The proposal to eliminate the terms “mother” and “father” in favor of more inclusive, gender non-specific language has been around since the 2013 debates held prior to the legalisation of same sex marriage.
“When I hear people say this is an old-fashioned model, I would remind people that today among unions celebrated, civil or marital, some 95 per cent are man-woman couples,” Conservative MP Xavier Breton said of the latest amendment, while fellow Conservative Fabien Di Filippo denounced the move as a “frightening ideology.”
However, it is not just conservatives who question the effectiveness of the new legislation. Alexandre Urwicz president of the AFDH, the French association for same sex parents, worries that the legislation could create a “parental hierarchy.”
“Who is ‘parent number 1’ and who is ‘parent number 2’?” he asks, adding that perhaps the less controversial “father, mother and legal representative,” be used instead.
The amendment may yet be rejected by the majority-Senate but would then return to France’s National Assembly for further consideration.
Debate is raging across French Twitter, though many have used the opportunity to ridicule the perceived overreaction on both sides of the argument.
#parent1Parent2 pic.twitter.com/oh5rKEmXPM
— Sentenza (@Perinetti_Yo) February 15, 2019
“My husband and I trying to decide who’s parent 1 and who’s parent 2,” joked one Twitter user.
⚡⚡ #parent1Parent2 : mon mari et moi, on se bat pour savoir qui sera le #parent1. Résultat : on est au bord du divorce ( le jour de la #SaintValentin !) pic.twitter.com/6ZqCU27bWP
— ツDelphine de Diesbach ツ (@DdeDiesbach) February 14, 2019
https://twitter.com/Claramilitch/status/1096013338125971456
https://www.rt.com/news/451539-parent1-parent2-mother-father-france/
kinda like when you need to go pea or shit.
Funny! Do you go pea or pee?
im bad
Oh, it wasn’t the Muslims in France that made this happen? I thought they were the sole problem(sarcasm).
Color me shocked. What’s “weimar” in French?
When shit like this happens, you know the system is totally lost….Torches and Pitchforks anyone..?
The problem is, they are arresting people over shit like this or not properly recycling their garbage and what not, or god forbid, making a racial joke or slur….
Such sensitive human beings over their in Europe, what happened to ya all….?
Hi Norm. Did the pendant arrive safely?
🙂
.