Begaye to sue Gold King Mine and EPA

Navajo Times – by Donovan Quintero

As Navajo Nation police and tribal officials went up and down the San Juan River shore Saturday warning community members of contaminated water from the Gold King Mine, Navajo Nation President Russell Begaye was making plans for a clean-up as well as possible lawsuits against the mine and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

“We are going to be suing for millions- billions of dollars,” Begaye said.  

Begaye and Navajo Vice President Jonathan Nez met with between 150 and 200 community members about 5:30 p.m. Saturday to give them an update on the situation.

Begaye said he learned on Wednesday that one million gallons of mine wastewater had breached a wall at the Gold King Mine near Silverton, Colo. and was heading for the Navajo reservation.

During an Aug. 5 excavation conducted by the EPA at the mine site, loose material gave way, spilling the contaminated water into Cement Creek, which feeds into the Animas River.

At that point. Begaye held a meeting with the NNEPA, Navajo Department of Transportation, NTUA and others to plan a strategy as they waited for the contaminated water to hit Upper Fruitland late Saturday morning.

He had two priorities: warning the Navajos in the area and making plans about what to do when the contaminated water finally reached the area.
Begay’s message gave three precautions for community members:

  • Prevent their livestock from drinking from the San Juan River.
  • Avoid diverting water from the river.
  • Do not enter the river.

He urged ranchers and farmers at the meeting Saturday to be especially careful of their livestock and their children and make sure they took steps to make everyone safe.

“We are going to make EPA pay for this,” he said, adding that he was going to work with NNEPA officials to do tests to see how serious the contamination was to Navajo lands.

He said he didn’t trust the EPA to do the tests because he felt the EPA would not tell them the truth and would try to get the tribe to settle for “pennies” instead of the millions or billions of dollars of damage that was done by the contaminated water.

As of Saturday, no one knew for certain just how serious the contamination was.

Photos of the water just south of the mine showed the river to be a dark mustard color but by the time it was getting to the reservation, it had obviously been diluted in part because of the decision to release more water from the Navajo Dam.

Begaye urged farmers and ranchers to make note of any damage the contaminated water did to their crops and their livestock so that the tribe could ask for damages for them as well.

One thing that is also uncertain is when and how long a clean up will take.

Begaye said he wanted it started as soon as possible, adding that one EPA official said the cleanup could take decades, a remark that got a visible reaction from the people in the audience.

Earl Yazzie, a farmer from Shiprock, said reports of the contamination was a “big blow to us.”

“This is stressing me out,” he added. “This is just not me but a lot of people are impacted who have farms to take care of.”

He added that water to the area has been off since Thursday.

Duane “Chili” Yazzie, president of the Shiprock Chapter as well as a farmer himself, said his biggest concern was how long before the water is turned back on.

“In two or three weeks, farming families are going to be hurting,” he said. “It’s their livelihood.”

Begaye said the areas that will affected will be affected stretch from the Upper Fruitland area to Lake Powell.” He said some 500 families live along that stretch of the San Juan River.

But this will also affect Navajo communities, such as Red Mesa, to the south and possibly even the Navajo-Gallup Water Pipeline which is currently under construction.

A map put on a chalkboard at the Shiprock Chapter House indicates that the contaminated water will reach Lake Powell at 8 p.m. on Wednesday, August 12.

A command center has been set at the Shiprock Chapter House. The number is there is 505-368-1037 or 928-871-7891.

5 thoughts on “Begaye to sue Gold King Mine and EPA

  1. This was so obviously an attack on the water supply. Who are these EPA Engineers who carried this out and obviously knew what was going to happen or are simply too stupid to live?

  2. Sadly it is US, not the EPA who will pay for this intentional mess. Win/win for them re this one so far:-/

  3. I live near the Navajo nation and I have met Mr. Begaye. If anyone can prevail against the feds, HE CAN.
    He’s a pleasant, but no bull shi#@ kind of guy, and his primary concern is the reservation and his people.
    Watch this closely, it could get interesting!

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *