Private citizens can ticket and arrest anyone for traffic violations in Tennessee


The American police state keeps growing, private citizens can stop, ticket and arrest anyone for a traffic violation:

The Newspaper:

The Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals on Friday decided to emphasize the private citizen’s right to pull over other motorists, even for minor traffic infractions. A three-judge panel reviewed the September 2, 2012 incident in which Pigeon Forge Police Officer Jeremy Croce stopped Steven Roy Wilburn outside of his jurisdiction.   

Though he did not realize it, the officer was not in Pigeon Forge — best known as the home of Dollywood — when he saw a lane violation. He had crossed into the neighboring town of Sevierville.The offense he witnessed was a Class C misdemeanor that is usually punished with a maximum fine of $50.

“As a private citizen, Officer Croce was authorized to stop and arrest defendant for these traffic violations.” Judge Timothy L. Easter wrote for the unanimous panel. “Officer Croce’s subjective belief that he was acting as a police officer in Sevierville rather than as a private citizenis immaterial.”

To operate under his authority as a city police officer, Officer Croce would have had to receive permission from Sevierville. He never asked for permission because he was not actually sure how far within that city’s limits he had driven. Officer Croce explained that he waited to pull Wilburn over because he wanted to give him “the benefit of the doubt” and ensure his weaving was not simply the result of a momentary lapse of concentration. At the suppression hearing, Officer Croce admitted that he did not develop any reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation until he had entered the Sevierville city limits.

Once stopped, however, it was clear Wilburn was driving under the influence of alcohol (DUI) from the odor of alcohol on his breath, his bloodshot eyes and slowed reactions. The allegations were backed up with dashcam video.

“Officer Croce was also authorized, as a private citizen, to arrest defendant for DUI,” Judge Easter ruled.

Tennessee law allows one private citizen to arrest another not just for the commission of a felony, but also for “a public offense committed in the arresting person’s presence.” The appellate judges cited a number of precedents that interpret a public offense to include misdemeanors, including traffic violations. For that reason, the court upheld Wilburn’s DUI conviction.

In Ohio, police can stop you because your car is loud and fast looking:

Daniyar Tuyakbayev, 30, found this out after driving in San Fransisco’s Presidio neighborhood about a half-hour before midnight on January 18, 2015. US Park Police Officer Eric Cole was standing behind a bus stop at Lincoln Boulevard and Pershing Drive, having pulled over another motorist. He says he heard the loud roar of Tuyakbayev’s 2014 Ford Mustang engine and, from a hundred yards away, he guessed it was traveling 20 MPH over the 30 MPH speed limit. He waved his flashlight, ordering Tuyakbayev to pull over.

“I was driving at the posted 30 miles per hour speed limit, and I did not exceed it,” Tuyakbayev testified.

US Magistrate Judge Maria-Elena James decided instead to believe the Park Police officer when he said the Mustang looked and sounded like it was going really fast.

“Officer Cole’s belief that defendant was speeding was not premised on a mere hunch, but rather, on Officer Cole’s observations that he heard defendant’s loud engine accelerating towards him and observed defendant’s car traveling at a very high rate of speed,” Judge James wrote. “Officer Cole also attests he was trained and certified to visually and accurately estimate the speed of a moving vehicle as part of his law enforcement duties.”

7 thoughts on “Private citizens can ticket and arrest anyone for traffic violations in Tennessee

  1. North Carolina is closely falling into step with the “police state” ideology as well. I hate just driving to work and back….never mind the idiots( on the government dole probably) crossing the double yellow line, speeding or tailgating in broad daylight…where are the cops then?

  2. So, does that mean any private citizen in that state can pull over a police officer on or off duty and ticket them?

    I can see what is coming next: “Court rules illegal aliens can arrest American Nationals for any reason they so choose.”

    1. You beat me to it, Sunfire. I was thinking the same thing. So does that mean a private citizen can ticket and arrest a cop for a traffic violation, like when he has parked his squad car in the middle of the road in order to try and catch people coming in the opposite direction in order to fill his quota for the month?

      This is a major traffic problem here in Texas because some people have to actually turn left in that lane and they just stop right in the middle of it without warning. If you or I did that, we’d be ticketed, but not them.

  3. like hell if im going to become a gestapo lackey .. I dont even agree with the blue man gang extracting revenue from any motorist , so like hell if im going to play like im part of their team

    If a Darwin award winner wants to kill himself i say more corn and biscuits for me

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *